One Year Later: Reflections on October 7

J Street community members, hostage families, and thought leaders share their reflections on this year of Hell and where we should go from here.

The Last War: A Proposal for Peace

Israeli peace advocate Maoz Inon writes, “The work of peace cannot wait until after the guns fall silent. It begins now – with every conversation.”

All Quiet on the Mediterranean Front

Peace activist and son of the late Vivian Silver, Yonatan Zeigen, writes, “It is an undeniable truth that Israelis will only be secure if Palestinians are free.”

Fighting for Life

Naama Weinberg, whose cousin Itai was murdered by Hamas, writes that the fight to bring the hostages home is a “fight for the soul of our society” and a “fight for us to remain a society that values life more than revenge."

Searching for Hope in the Future of Israel

Diana Clark of Massachusetts shares, “if you have hope, please, please hope. Hope for us all. But I am reconciled to loss, including the loss of hope that Israel will ever be for me what I had hoped it would be: a place where the rights...

History Shows, Living by the Sword Will Not Bring Peace

Dr. Yasmeen Abu Fraiha, a peace advocate and physician, shares, “No one will be safe as long as we are not all safe, free and equal to each other – from the river to the sea.”

A Year Since October 7, Hope is a Mandatory Practice, a Radical Act

Rabbi Claudia Kreiman of Massachusetts writes, “Even as we have witnessed the worst of what humanity is capable of, we have also witnessed acts of profound grace and courage.”

To Bear Witness and to Move Forward with Purpose

University of Pennsylvania Law Professor Abby Tolchinsky writes, “We must find ways to build a better tomorrow and, by doing so, honor the memory of those massacred.”

The Poison of Antisemitism

Sebastien Levi writes, “Antisemitism is all the more poisonous when it turns into a tendency to see antisemitism everywhere, even in good faith criticisms of the Israeli government and its policies."

Holding Space for Humanity and Hope

Paula Weiss of New York writes “I needed to keep open the space for holding multiple truths at once, a space that recognizes Israel’s need for security and its right to exist along with the imperative that Israel adhere to the rule of law."

Holding Inspiration and Pain

Rabbi John Rosove of Los Angeles shares, “I worry about the diminishing good name of Israel, the rise of antisemitism, and that so many have lost their moral compass.”

Prayers for a New Year

Alma Rutgers of Connecticut writes, “We can’t wish away this past year. But with the gates of heaven open at Rosh Hashanah, we can let our prayers ascend, embracing hope for a good inscription in our Book of Life."

Uniting to Bring the Hostages Home

Efrat Machikawa, whose 80-year-old uncle Gadi Moses is still held in Gaza, writes, “Watching the way Netanyahu handles the situation is sickening to many of us. He’s been able to blind the Israeli public and empower a loud extremist group.

Jewish Resilience on this Somber Anniversary

Michael Seiden of Arizona writes, “Those of us who feel concern for the hundreds of thousands of Palestinians are not outcasts to our religion.”

Sustaining Hope One Year After October 7

Rabbi Shalom Bochner of Petaluma, CA shares two personal reflections, one from immediately after October 7 and from one year later, “I know that I’m an optimist, and I’ve been called unrealistic, naïve, self-hating, and lots of other...

Mourn the Dead. Fight like Hell for the Living.

NYU J Street U student leader Joseph Hillyard writes, “As I prepare for a week of memorials and reflections upon this very difficult year, I have one single thought: Mourn the dead, fight like hell for the living.”