As the politics around Israel grow ever more polarized and toxic inside and out of the Jewish community, the notion that there’s a ‘mainstream consensus’ of Jewish opinion on Israel may seem far-fetched.
But between the banging drums of anti-Zionists on the far-left and the enraged bluster of the “Israel can do no wrong” crowd on the right lies an extremely large mainstream majority of Jewish Americans holding a nuanced, balanced opinion of the issue.
This mainstream consensus – found at what I call the 50-yard line of American Jewish opinion – is found in poll after poll showing a healthy majority of Jews who care about Israel, oppose Netanyahu, support Palestinian self-determination and want the US to exercise balanced, pro-peace leadership…